You are hereBlog / Weird story, bad photo


Weird story, bad photo

Aug 18 2008 1:24am
MSNBC headlines a story on Israel's shutting the doors to further Ethiopian immigration with a photo of Jerusalem policemen violently subduing an Ethiopian protester. The photo seems inappropriate in the context. The story is about complex issues of identity and assimilation. The photo has nothing to do with the story, but instead tries to provoke the American audience's gut reaction of white men subduing a black man. The issue is far more about the Ethiopian immigrants' primitive backgrounds, rather than race; assimilating thousands of people who have never used a flush toilet into a modern society is bound to be complicated.
Maybe the MSNBC editors are simply asking whether Israel's "right of return" is itself racist. A fair question, but why not just ask it straight out?
Or maybe there's something wrong with the American do-gooders who set up these camps for Ethiopians to prepare for moving to Israel. The scene in Charlie Wilson's War of evangelical congressmen in Pakistani refugee camps comes to mind. Or Kipling's poem about the "white man's burden." If Ethiopian villagers need modern conveniences so much, wouldn't it make more sense to simply donate those, rather than pressure another country to adopt them?

Site News

  • BenBuckman.net 2.0 launched! (12/28)

Coming Soon

  • Blog topics & archives
  • Weewar game tracker
  • More time for actual blogging...

Recent Posts

Blog-only RSS feed
Jan 5 2009 2:26am
Sloppy Reporting
Jan 4 2009 11:32pm
What I did on New Years Eve
Jan 2 2009 3:36pm
If only we'd just get along...
Dec 31 2008 6:12pm
My new Yaris
Dec 31 2008 3:59pm
Phased-in Gas Tax
Dec 30 2008 2:37am
Bush's Legacy
Dec 29 2008 11:55pm
Catching up on Moyers
Dec 29 2008 11:50pm
The Buck St0p 2.0 Beta is LIVE!!!
Dec 28 2008 11:05pm
Happy Holidays
Dec 24 2008 1:07pm

Travels

Hawaii, Israel, and more coming soon